About Us

Nutty’s Old Fashioned Peanut Butter started years ago in the mind of a little girl who always wanted to open her own peanut butter and jelly shop. As an adult, Carrie’s kitchen became her lab, where crazy concoctions emerged.  In 2002 with the help of her husband Keith they opened The Original Peanut Butter Emporium in Overton, Texas. Carrie and Keith have combined their love of history and nostalgia with their love of peanut butter to create a unique peanut butter experience. 

We would like to invite you to come by and visit us in Jefferson, Texas.

While you'’re here be sure to try any of our delicious, fresh milled flavored peanut butters.