My Peanut Butter Box Monthly Subscription

A little something extra this October! ☕🎁

Subscribe to My Peanut Butter Box by October 12 and get a FREE PB Cup coffee tucked into your first Box!

Your October Box ships October 13. You'll receive two jars of freshly milled Nutty's peanut butter, including one exclusive mystery flavor you won't find on our shelves.

Just $20/month.

Free coffee offer for new and returning subscribers while supplies last.

Fresh milled goodness delivered right to your door every month! My Peanut Butter Box is a monthly subscription for you or someone you love! Two fresh milled peanut butters are chosen especially for you - and one of them is an exclusive, brand-new flavor, exclusive to the box!

You’ll be charged on the first of each month, and your box will ship soon afterward. Cancel at any time. 

Past Box shown. Flavors change monthly!