My Peanut Butter Box Monthly Subscription

Two jars. One exclusive flavor. A new peanut butter surprise every month. 🥜

Your next little box of happy ships November 11! 🥜

Join My Peanut Butter Box by November 10 to receive two jars of freshly milled Nutty’s peanut butter—including one exclusive surprise flavor you won’t find on our shelves.

$20/month plus shipping calculated at checkout. Local pickup available in Jefferson, Texas.

A fresh surprise every month. Cancel anytime!

Fresh milled goodness delivered right to your door every month! My Peanut Butter Box is a monthly subscription for you or someone you love! Two fresh milled peanut butters are chosen especially for you - and one of them is an exclusive, brand-new flavor, exclusive to the box!

Your first payment is charged when you subscribe and covers your November Box, shipping November 11. Your next payment will be December 1, then on the first of each month after that. Cancel anytime.

Past Box shown. Flavors change monthly!